There is something revealing about the contemporary obsession with the term immersive. Increasingly, entertainment attractions, exhibitions and cultural institutions advertise themselves as offering immersive experiences. What does this usually entail? Large-scale video projections, elaborate lighting, enveloping sound systems and digitally animated environments, wrapped up in marketing spiel promising to transport visitors into another world, or to experience such and such an artist “like never before”. The appeal is ostensibly one of participation, where rather than simply looking at something inert, we are invited to enter it, to become surrounded by it and to experience it from within.
I’ve generally avoided these kinds of attractions; faintly bristling at the sight of the word IMMERSIVE on marketing posters and digital advertising blurb covering everything from Tutankhamun to Pompeii and space exploration. I do recall visiting one of these things in Istanbul a few years ago, which had been setup in one of the city’s many underground cisterns. As Roman architecture goes, they are comparatively unadorned and functional structures, which apart from the characteristic forest of columns have little else to stimulate the dopamine hungry tourist. So, to augment the large airy space they had installed an audio-visual show consisting of various scenes from Istanbul’s history set to stirring orchestral music and a lightshow which took advantage of the repetitive architectural geometry of the cistern to throw eye-catching combinations of colour and shadow around the vaults and shallow pools of water.
It lasted about ten minutes, then after a short interval began again. We watched it play through twice, trying while the light was more natural to take stock of the actual space and its visual heritage. It felt trite and forced, but my fellow tourists evidently felt differently and had filled the time with the usual taking of photos and videos with their phones. Per minute it was probably one of the most expensive things we did that week, and yet upon leaving I felt there was little – apart from the nagging sense of being ripped off – that lodged in my memory. I’m perhaps not the target audience for this sort of attraction, nevertheless the immersive form of entertainment consumption is becoming almost inescapable, and this deserves some thought.
The etymology of the word is suggestive. Derived from the Latin immergere, meaning to plunge or submerge, immersion implies a movement from outside to inside, from separation to enclosure. Something immersive doesn’t just present an object for our consideration, it attempts to surround us with it. The distinction might initially seem trivial, but it points towards a significant transformation in the relationship between cultural objects, spectators and the organisation of attention.
Consider the difference between visiting an art gallery and attending a commercial immersive exhibition devoted to the work of Vincent van Gogh, such as the one which was in London until recently. In the former, we encounter paintings as discrete objects. We can approach them, withdraw, look at individual details, compare them with other works or simply stand and contemplate them. The painting does not necessarily demand our attention, nor does it continually offer something new to hold it. We must bring something of ourselves to the encounter and that encounter may at first be underwhelming. We must learn how to look, to exercise our imagination and to establish relationships between what we see and what we already know.
The immersive Van Gogh exhibition, by contrast, takes the paintings and transforms them into enormous projections, animated sequences and audiovisual environments through which visitors move. Music establishes an emotional atmosphere, images expand across walls and floors, and lighting and movement combine to produce a continuous spectacle. Rather than searching within the painting for something that might sustain our attention, the environment supplies an immediate and ongoing succession of sensory stimuli. One is tempted to cite Paul Valéry’s comment – much beloved of Francis Bacon – that nowadays people want the sensation without the boredom of its conveyance. But unlike the paintings of Francis Bacon, whose distorted figures transmit sensation directly to the nervous system, before it can resolve itself into representation or narrative, the immersive attraction reaches us through the brute force of an apparatus of attentional capture.
The gallery encounter preserves a distance between spectator and object, a distance within which interpretation, imagination and recollection can take place and through which a deeper encounter can perhaps be reached. The immersive attraction instead attempts to abolish that distance. Its promise of greater participation – or at the very least a more intense encounter - conceals a paradox: although the visitor becomes physically more involved, they may become intellectually less active. The environment and meticulously designed “user experience” determines what is seen, when it is seen, how it moves and the emotional register through which it is experienced.
There is I believe more at stake here than just two different ways of appreciating art, and it isn’t reducible to a question of high culture versus popular entertainment. It concerns two very different ways of organising human attention, which in turn point to some of the most profound changes underway in modern society.
The Architecture of Attention
This rise of immersive entertainment becomes particularly significant when considered through the work of the French philosopher of technology Bernard Stiegler and his critique of the contemporary attention economy. For Stiegler, attention is not simply an innate psychological capacity that individuals either possess or lack. It is cultivated through social practices, institutions and technical environments. Reading, education, religious ritual and artistic contemplation are all forms through which attention is developed and transmitted. Conversely, industrial systems, most notably the industrial systems of networked digital culture, increasingly treat attention as a resource to be captured, channelled and monetised.
The contemporary immersive attraction can be understood as an architectural extension of this process. We normally associate the attention economy with screens, smartphones and algorithmically managed social media feeds, but its logic is increasingly being transferred into physical space. Instead of scrolling through a succession of images, the visitor moves through a succession of rooms, projections, soundscapes and installations. The visitor effectively scrolls with their body, an activity which in the context of traditional museums I’ve elsewhere called Doomstrolling.
It’s worth noting that this form of entertainment consumption is only the latest phase in a long historical trajectory. Over the past century, audiovisual entertainment has progressively increased its capacity to occupy the perceptual field. Cinema gave way to television, which brought its own programmatic time regime into the home. Colour television then expanded to increasingly large domestic screens, and conventional cinema formats to IMAX, surround sound and other technologies designed to intensify sensory involvement. Virtual reality and environmental projection take this development further still until the consumer reaches a point Stiegler has called affective saturation, which is the result of this hyper-solicitation of attention.
The underlying logic is one of escalation. Yesterday's extraordinary stimulus becomes today's perceptual baseline. Technologies designed to capture attention may themselves contribute to a situation in which earlier forms of stimulation become less capable of sustaining it. Like an addict developing a tolerance, the consumer requires increasingly intense experiences to achieve the same degree of engagement; a demand for which the market is all too happy to respond. Sensory escalation thus compensates for a diminished capacity for sustained attention.
The consequences of this at scale, according to Stiegler, are the society wide disruption and short circuiting of process of identification, which in the psychoanalytic theory of development are central to the formation of stable socialised individuals and collectives. The philosopher’s prognosis is bleak; when attentional formation is “ceded to the flux of industrial temporal objects” which is now controlled by a small cabal of media and technology companies, the end result is not only “psychic dis-identification” but also “collective disindividualisation, that is, to a destruction of the social body itself, and engenders disaffected psychic and social individuals”. These words, written in the summer of 2005, partly in response to the riots which took place on the outskirts of French cities the previous November (which incidentally I also witnessed), cannot but strike the observer 20 years hence as prophetic.
The comparison with drug addiction is an analogy, but our increasing familiarity with the dopamine economy – coextensive with the attention economy - brings it close to something of a literal physiological claim, but moreover it describes an important cultural tendency. As attention becomes habituated to continuous novelty and stimulation, relatively quiet cultural objects struggle to compete. One thing that strikes you about Van Gogh’s pictures if you visit them in Amsterdam is their small scale, in stark contrast to the floor to ceiling projections in the London immersive show.
The museum is consequently tempted to adapt itself to the very conditions that threaten its traditional function. Where once it might have invited us simply to contemplate a Van Gogh painting, it now feels compelled to enlarge, animate and surround us with Van Gogh, animate him, force him to come to us, rather than leaving the work to the viewer. As Stiegler puts it, the cumulative effect of this transformation is that the age of the ‘amateur’, the art-lover, comes to be replaced by the consumer suffering a dazed cultural obesity”.
The danger here is that institutions historically concerned with cultivating attention increasingly reorganise themselves around its capture. Where they may once have viewed at least part of their remit to be a corrective to the tendencies of mass media, now they have begun to reproduce them within their own spaces, using their collections as available material for “content”. Less and less do museums and galleries introduce visitors to a different temporal order, a refuge from the outside world of acceleration and optimisation. Instead, amid a general funding crisis in the arts, they compete for available brain time inside the same economy of novelty.
This helps explain why cultural institutions can remain outwardly dedicated to heritage while becoming structurally indifferent to transmission. They retain the aura of culture and even reproduce something of the sacred architecture of cultural authority in their vast halls but convert that aura into a purchasable event. We might conclude then that immersion is the aesthetic technology through which cultural inheritance is adapted to the requirements of mass entertainment, the nadir of which is the famed Auschwitz Selfie.
A fundamental casualty of this process is boredom. In a conventional gallery, boredom is not necessarily a failure. Standing before a painting and initially finding nothing particularly interesting can be the beginning of a more sustained encounter. Older forms of art, particularly religious art operate with their own iconographic language and conventions which take time to learn to read. Remaining with the object allows distinctions to emerge such as brushwork, composition, colour relationships, historical references and other details that might otherwise escape notice. The spectator must cross a threshold of perceptual resistance which is made especially hard when one’s attention is being constantly solicited elsewhere.
Yet this resistance is inextricably bound up with individual cultural formation which always involves an asymmetry between the person one presently is and the capacities for understanding one has not yet acquired. One must learn to read a difficult novel, hear the structure of unfamiliar music, recognise artistic conventions or situate an object historically. Commercial immersion minimises this burden. It makes high culture accessible not principally by cultivating new capacities in the visitor, but by translating cultural objects into a sensory language the consumer already understands, with boredom thus cast as a mortal enemy to be avoided at all costs.
This hostility to boredom acquires a deeper significance if considered alongside Martin Heidegger's reflections on the experience from his 1929–30 lectures The Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics. Heidegger distinguishes ordinary instances of being bored by particular things from what he calls profound boredom, in which it is not simply that this or that object has failed to interest us but that things as a whole seem to withdraw their significance. This mode of boredom is uncomfortable precisely because the usual distractions through which we occupy ourselves cease to work.
Yet for Heidegger this is philosophically productive, as deprived of their ordinary solicitations we become aware of our own relation to time and of the world as a whole in a manner normally concealed by everyday activity. “Boredom is accordingly the fundamental attunement of our philosophizing, in which we develop the three questions of world, finitude and individuation. Time is thereby itself something that determines us in the working out of these three guiding questions. If time is tied up with boredom, and on the other hand is somehow the basis for our three questions, then the fundamental attunement of boredom constitutes an exceptional relation to time in human Dasein”.
Considered from this perspective, the contemporary determination to eradicate every interval of boredom becomes more significant than a simple preference for entertainment. The immersive attraction, like the smartphone feed, supplies an environment in which the moment attention begins to loosen from one stimulus another is already waiting to claim it. What is thereby eliminated is not merely boredom but the possibility contained within boredom; the unoccupied interval in which attention might cease responding to external stimuli and turn instead towards recollection, reflection or contemplation. The attention economy can therefore be revealed not only as an apparatus for capturing attention, but as an apparatus increasingly organised to prevent the experience of its absence and thus contributes to a profound concealment of the world.
The question is therefore not simply whether an immersive attraction produces a memorable experience. It may well do so. The more important question is what kind of memory it produces and how much interpretative work the individual has undertaken in producing it. When the emotional and perceptual associations of an artwork are supplied in advance, we risk receiving something like prefabricated recollection: the cultural object arrives already packaged with instructions about how it should be experienced. In effect it becomes little more than the memory of a sensation.
The Cathedral and the Religious Organisation of Attention
There is, however, an important complication to this argument. If we follow Stiegler in adopting a pharmacological approach to immersive technologies - which recognises their potential as both remedy and poison - then immersion alone cannot be the root of the problem. Religious architecture, Gothic cathedrals, Mosques and ritual environments of many kinds, have all historically employed forms of sensory enclosure, monumental scale, music, illumination and collective movement to produce profoundly immersive experiences for the participants. The cathedral offers a particularly revealing counterexample to the commercial attractions we’ve so far discussed because it demonstrates that an environment can organise attention without necessarily capturing it.
Cathedrals are extraordinarily sophisticated attentional environments, the apogee if you like of Medieval technologies of the spirit. Their architecture establishes an axis leading from the entrance towards the altar. Its height and vaulting draw the eye upwards, while stained glass, sculpture and religious imagery situate individual objects within the broader Christian narrative. Music, bells, processions and the liturgical calendar further organise the experience of the building through the seasons. But the purpose of this organisation is not to maintain continuous sensory stimulation. On the contrary, Christian ritual incorporates silence, waiting, kneeling, listening, repetitive prayer and contemplation. These are not interruptions to the experience but integral components of it.
The distinction becomes even clearer when we consider the role of participation. Commercial immersive attractions frequently promise to transform spectators into participants. Yet this participation often amounts to little more than moving through a predetermined environment, looking, photographing and occasionally interacting with installations before landing inevitably in the gift shop. The visitor's body is involved, but the environment continues to do most of the perceptual and aesthetic labour. Liturgical participation is fundamentally different. The collective activity of the congregation is constitutive of the event itself. The worshipper is not simply an audience member observing a show but a participant in a practice with a long heritage that precedes any particular occasion and continues beyond it.
Here again we encounter the distinction between apparatuses of attentional formation and those of attentional capture. The former cultivates capacities that can be exercised beyond the immediate experience, which establishes relationships between present perception, memory, inherited narratives and interpretation. We might even suggest that the fundamental object of attention in all religious ritual is time itself in the form of human mortality set against eternal things. Heidegger’s description of profound boredom opening up an experience of the fundamental questions of world, finitude and individuation seems to echo this in secular form. This “awakening to a fundamental attunement” stands in stark contrast with the mode of attentional capture which continually solicits attention, minimises opportunities for withdrawal and directs individuals towards consumption of the immediate stimulus.
At the heart of the cathedral’s spiritual technology is transcendence. The images and architecture are not the end point in the movement of attention. A stained-glass representation of the Crucifixion is not just an aesthetically impressive image, its significance depends upon its relationship to scripture, Christian teaching and the worshipper's own understanding of suffering, death and redemption. The totality of the experience directs attention beyond the sensory environment towards something understood to exceed it.
The anagogical role of Christian practices, including artistic and architectural forms was given its paradigmatic treatment by Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, for whom anagogy (from the Greek anagōgē, meaning 'leading upwards' or 'ascent') is the process by which the human mind is elevated from the material, sensible world towards an apprehension of divine reality. It is a central principle of his mystical theology and, more broadly, his understanding of how symbols, images, rituals and intellectual contemplation can transform human consciousness.
According to this interpretation the cathedral is therefore not merely an immersive environment, but an environment organised around and directed towards transcendence itself. Perhaps there is a residue of this transcendent anagogical structure of attentional engagement remaining in the promise of contemporary immersive entertainment, one that might help explain its growing popularity more fully than the demand for sensory stimulation alone.
A Simulacrum of Transcendence
The history of our species testifies to the human desire for experiences that take us outside the routines and limitations of ordinary existence. Religious ritual, pilgrimage and sacred architecture have frequently provided forms through which this desire could be articulated. They offered experiences of wonder, collective belonging and transcendence, organised around something understood to be more real or more significant than the routines of everyday life.
The weakening of religious institutions in modern secular societies in the wake of detraditionalisation has, however, not necessarily eliminated this desire. What it has done is to leave this desire for transcendence without most of the traditional forms through which it was previously expressed. Now commercial immersive entertainment enters to exploit this condition of yearning. Its spatial organisation often borrows the morphology of sacred spaces, for example monumental scale, darkness and illumination, enveloping music, enclosure, collective experience, procession and a carefully controlled passage through successive environments. There is an attempt to provide a sense of entering another world, temporarily leaving ordinary time and space behind.
These attractions consequently promise two things simultaneously: stimulate me more intensely and take me outside of ordinary life. These desires are not necessarily contradictory. Indeed, they may help explain why increasingly sophisticated forms of audiovisual entertainment are insufficient on their own. The consumer wants more than a larger television or a louder cinema. They want an experience of ascent, presence and wonder. The explosion of the spiritual wellness industry, not to mention fanciful discussions about a “re-enchantment of the world” is another manifestation of this.
Yet there is a fundamental difference between the transcendent experience offered by religious ritual and its commercial imitation. In the cathedral, sensory experience is directed beyond itself within the context of a heritage that stretches back centuries. Architecture, music and imagery are meaningful because they point towards something that is not reducible to their immediate sensory or material qualities. Commercial immersion tends to reverse this relationship. Its sensory effects become their own object. The experience is ultimately about the experience and nothing else: the extraordinary sensation of being surrounded by extraordinary sensations.
This is little more than a simulacrum of transcendence, one which accords well with contemporary nihilism – that will-to-will, which Heidegger identified as the dead-end of Nietzsche’s philosophy. It reproduces some of the formal conditions historically associated with sacred experience while removing the transcendent object towards which those conditions were directed. We retain the enclosure, wonder, and some of the sensory stimuli and collective excitement, but what lies beyond ordinary experience is simply something more intense than ordinary experience, not more real and rarely more meaningful. These are insufficient conditions for cultural transmission or even stable memory formation.
Which points us towards a familiar characteristic of contemporary entertainment, the difficulty of articulating what one has actually experienced. A visitor returns from an immersive attraction saying that it was “incredible”, “amazing” or something that you really had to experience for yourself. These descriptions, common in the marketing material for such attractions, are not necessarily evidence of an impoverished intellect. They may accurately reflect an experience whose principal content was all sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Compare this with standing before a particular painting, let’s say the Ghent Altarpiece or Picasso's Guernica, for fifteen minutes. The immediate sensory impact might be considerably less impressive, but afterwards there may be much more to think about: an unusual composition, a disturbing expression, a particular use of colour or something about the artwork’s historical circumstances. One experience can be sensorially dense but semantically thin; the other sensorially sparse but semantically dense. It testifies to our symbolic immiseration (to use another of Stiegler’s concepts) that so much of the media landscape fits the former description.
As already suggested, immersive entertainment may also be antithetical to those processes of individuation described by Stiegler, because it increasingly performs the work of attention, interpretation and memory on the participant’s behalf. Individuation is not merely the expression of an already formed self, but the continuing formation of the self through active encounters with inherited cultural forms and with the collective memory they embody. Such encounters require time, interpretative effort and the possibility of relating cultural objects to one’s own experience. In our interpretation, immersive attractions instead attempt to pre-structure this encounter through sensory enclosure. By minimising those intervals of boredom, distance and ambiguity in which a person might interpret and assimilate what is encountered, it short-circuits both psychic individuation and participation in a shared cultural inheritance.
The Experience of the Experience as Recursive Trap
There is a final irony in the relationship between immersive entertainment and the attention economy. The more effectively industrial commercial systems capture attention, the more they may contribute to the very dissatisfaction and disaffection that drives consumers towards increasingly elaborate experiences.
The attention economy does not simply supply entertainment to an existing consumer desire. It also helps produce the conditions under which that desire is formed and operates. Continuous novelty establishes expectations, habituation to sensory intensity raises the threshold of stimulation, and the resulting difficulty of sustaining attention creates demand for ever more intense forms of engagement. The cycle becomes self-reinforcing, and we can easily see the impact of this on a daily basis in interactions with our permanently distracted fellow citizens. Look around a train carriage at the grim faces glued to screens and it’s hard not to see yourself surrounded by addicts.
At the same time, the commodification of experience offers to satisfy desires that cannot ultimately be satisfied through consumption alone. The primordial desire for transcendence is converted into a purchasable experience, but because the experience has no object beyond itself, its intensity is necessarily temporary and ultimately spiritually impoverishing. Once it has ended, another experience must be sought, which is the basic structure of addiction. Contrast this with liturgical repetition where the worshipper returns to the same ritual time and again because its object is understood to be inexhaustible.
This is perhaps the central problem with contemporary immersive entertainment. It’s not simply that modern technology has come to organise perception, since – following Steigler, all cultures have developed technologies, institutions and practices through which attention is formed. Nor is the problem that sensory experience is necessarily opposed to contemplation. The cathedral and other religious spaces demonstrate otherwise.
The decisive question is what kind of relationship between attention, memory and desire a particular environment seeks to establish. Does it cultivate our capacity to attend to things beyond the immediate stimulus, or does it attempt to monopolise attention within an endlessly renewed sequence of stimuli for the sake of profit? Does it direct us towards something that exceeds the experience (an example of Steigler’s “long circuits of investment”), or does it make the experience itself the ultimate object of desire, at best to be memorialised in a souvenir from the gift shop?
The proliferation of immersive entertainment thus suggests that the contemporary attention economy is moving beyond the capture of available brain time towards something more ambitious and potentially more destructive. It increasingly seeks to satisfy, through consumption, needs that were once articulated through contemplation, ritual and transcendence but ultimately just amplifies disaffection and addictive behaviours.
The immersive Van Gogh exhibition and the Istanbul cistern are therefore more than relatively trivial examples of contemporary cultural kitsch. It is a revealing expression of two characteristic movements within late capitalist society; an escalating technological struggle to extract profits by overcoming our inability to attend, and an escalating experiential struggle to overcome our incapacity to transcend. As pithy as that formulation may sound, the generalisation of this movement marks a new phase in the total proletarianisation of populations of the most advanced economies; robbing them of both their savoir faire and savoir vivre.
















